Thread: Chapter 218 Discussion

u guys are all hypocrites ... all the guys dream of a harem or seem very fine/please with Harima deserve this girl or that girl or both lol ha ha ha ha and all acting angry when the girl seem ( the situation still very unclear ) dating more than 1 guy ... come on get real they not married yet and love or sex (married is final process) like buy a car ... how the heck u know that car run well if u not give its some test driving ( well some girl teach me that in a very open conversation and my world turned up side down but must agreed with her later on )

.....what?

Originally Posted by gooeygarth

.....what?

Wait wait...I think I can get this.

You guys are all hypocrites. All you guys dream of a harem, and seem very fine with Harima bouncing between this girl or that girl or both (lol, ha ha ha) and you act all angry when a girl is dating more then one guy. Come on, get real. They are not married yet. Love and sex is like buying a car. How the heck do you know that a car runs well unless you test drive it. Well, in a very open conversation, some girl taught me that and my world was turned upside down. But now I must agree with her.

Proper grammar and punctuation (more or less) FTW.

Originally Posted by Kyto1984

Wait wait...I think I can get this.

You guys are all hypocrites. All you guys dream of a harem, and seem very fine with Harima bouncing between this girl or that girl or both (lol, ha ha ha) and you act all angry when a girl is dating more then one guy. Come on, get real. They are not married yet. Love and sex is like buying a car. How the heck do you know that a car runs well unless you test drive it. Well, in a very open conversation, some girl taught me that and my world was turned upside down. But now I must agree with her.

Proper grammar and punctuation (more or less) FTW.

and amazingly it still makes no sense

I believe filler is the most suitable word for this chapter. I was disappointed by it, although not really surprised since there's no better time for the less important characters to show up.

Originally Posted by InfernalAngel

u guys are all hypocrites ... all the guys dream of a harem or seem very fine/please with Harima deserve this girl or that girl or both lol ha ha ha ha and all acting angry when the girl seem ( the situation still very unclear ) dating more than 1 guy ... come on get real they not married yet and love or sex (married is final process) like buy a car ... how the heck u know that car run well if u not give its some test driving ( well some girl teach me that in a very open conversation and my world turned up side down but must agreed with her later on )

Let me try translating it:

This section has become a filthy den of hypocrisy...

When it's about matters of courtship for Harima, anything goes, even him having his own harem; it's just a joke. However, this girl Madoka is being condemned for the same things we laugh about Harima possibly doing before we even know the extent of her situation! Come on, so what if she's dating more than one guy!? Madoka's not married to Umeda, so it's not like she's committed herself to spending the rest of her life with him! Ease off on her, already!

You see, Madoka's promiscuous behaviour can be compared to the testing of automobiles prior to the purchasing of a vehicle. People need to associate with multiple members of the opposite sex before choosing one to marry in order to determine which one best suits their need, much like how test-driving cars before buying them is necessary to avoid being stuck with a vehicle that doesn't perform well. In short, an incompatible partner is as unwanted as a faulty car.

A girl brought this to my attention in a rather open discussion that simply floored me. Nonetheless, I came to concur with her ideas as time passed and believe you should be viewing Madoka's flings with other men from the same perspective as mine.

I'm really really sorry to cause misunderstanding because my bad habit in writing wrong grammar sentences and careless punctuation, I’ll re-check my post properly from now on. Thanks Utralness and Kyto to spend ur time to correct my mistakes.

My main idea is don't be so mean to her, in SC universe things happen not according to how it should look like, maybe she’s not actually cheating at all, or she has her very own reason. Umh we fanboy (oh well fangirls) always hope the lead male end up with the female character(s) we like even sometime he already had one, so why Madoka can't reconsider of her choice, if the bind not strong enough to keep 2 peoples together then let break up instead of causing pain to each others, don't try to make any side look bad or he/she is the one who made mistake and should be sorry for that.

@ -Ajax- : i really like ur screen name, its 1 of my most favorite web programming technique now, and I’m used that for most of my projects lol, the thing annoy me is just i have o write back button functions for most of them lol

Please forgive me if I made grammar mistake again.

Originally Posted by InfernalAngel

if the bind not strong enough to keep 2 peoples together then let break up instead of causing pain to each others

But the thing is, she hasn't broken up with him yet and she's sticking wang in her tang (maybe).

I don't believe in Harima having more than one girl, and therefore I see no reason to assume that a couple that got along as well as Umeda and Madoka shouldn't stay together with no cheating on either side. She made a commitment to him by agreeing to date him, and so by cheating she's hurting him. This isn't like testing a car at all - these are people involved. It wouldn't be right with any other School Rumble character and it isn't right for her.

Yeah, I'm really starting to hate Madoka now. I was writing a ShigeoxMadoka fanfic, in which she had a completely different character based on the earlier hints, but this chapter broke it completely. 15 pages of script, gone down the drain.

I agree with D_E. No cheating characters allowed in School Rumble. Not unless it's used to comedic effect, like Kuno in Ranma 1/2. It's just plain... wrong, and out-of-setting. I mean, when you think about all the efforts that the main cast go through in order to even TRY and establish a relationship, and then you see Madoka carelessly throwing the only one in existence away, it's just so... pitiful. She deserves to get her heart broken. I hope Shigeo finds out and dumps her... and then finds someone else.

EDIT: People can play around, fine... as long as they are honest about it. Imadori and Saeko are good examples of this. But they're still unattached. What I find disgusting is Madoka hiding it from Shigeo, and even bribing Suga with a kiss to keep it quiet.

-Dizzy-

SC don't have character with totally bad personality or at least not yet appear. Things happen around in crumble way to make the manga a totally comedy show, so y ur guys rush to the conclusion that she’s cheating … and even she would there will be a very funny way of explanation mangaka will come up with. Actually, even when in real life u dating someone later you feel bore with ur lover then jump to a fast train love adventure then leave the train sooner or later with just few emotions left to return to ur old one like nothing happen, well it’s definitely not good example for moral stuff but that just a very normal thing happen a lot in real life since I not yet make an oath in the church I still have the right to chose again, the point is take it easy things always not as bad as u image and especially in SC universe.

Well I tho that I express my point of view about this chapter quite clear and even u guys try to convince me with ur point of view I sill want to keep my way of thinking … so I tho I will skip argue on this matter with ur guys … is this ok, I’m dead tire of keyboard boxing already.

and again forgive me if i make grammar mistake lol