
Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
Yakumo feels that Harima and Tenma would be a good couple, so from her perspective it is in Tenma's interest to promote Tenma/Harima.
I'm not arguing whether or not Yakumo is purposely trying to hurt Tenma. I agree with you that she's acting in accordance for what she believes to be right, and that what's she doing is what she thinks will make Tenma happy.
My problem with Yakumo’s matchmaking is that it is not in Tenma’s interest to get together with Harima right now, since Tenma still wants to get together with Karasuma. Another problem I have is Yakumo deciding her choice for the ideal man for Tenma is better than Tenma’s choice with making no effort to learn a little more about Karasuma; I think Yakumo should put more trust in her sister’s decisions.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
I don't think that the last page of 206 symbolizes anything specific beyond Tenma not knowing Harima and Yakumo's feelings, as said in the sidetext, and things going wrong and being generally very complicated.
The side text at the end of Chapter 206 doesn’t say anything about Tenma not knowing about Harima’s feelings; it says “The younger sister’s heart, the older sister doesn’t know...” The note just says that Tenma doesn’t know Yakumo’s “heart.” Don’t loosely paraphrase side text and change its meaning.
If the scene of Iori knocking off Harima’s head after Yakumo symbolically pairs him with Tenma isn’t a symbolic warning for Yakumo not to support “Oudou,” then why did Kobayashi have Iori do it? How does it relate to Tenma not knowing Harima and Yakumo’s feelings, and how does it make you feel that things are simply going to get wrong and be generally complicated?
Give me some reasons to believe that your interpretation of the scene is better than mine, or how Iori lopping off Harima’s head isn’t symbolizing Yakumo should not support Oudou.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
Yakumo is not to blame for Eri's reaction and Tenma's subsequent suffering; that is entirely Eri's fault.
I agree Yakumo isn’t to blame for Eri’s inability to deal with her jealousy; those are Eri’s flaws and they existed before this happened, and I think it’s up to Eri to deal with the feud with Tenma, not Yakumo.
However, Yakumo is responsible for Eri’s flaws resurfacing, and that has indirectly caused Tenma to suffer. Thus, Yakumo is partially responsible for her sister’s pain, even though Eri is the one directly causing the pain.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
Yakumo had no way of knowing what would happen; if Tenma was killed by a meteorite while working on manga with Harima, it would be an indirect result of Yakumo's suggestion but certainly wouldn't be Yakumo's fault.
Yakumo had a feud with Eri after Yakumo spent time with Harima way back in the Play arc, and Eri’s actions in Chapter 205 should have been enough for Yakumo to know that pressing Tenma onto Harima would cause Eri to get angry at Tenma, causing Tenma pain.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
Yakumo only gave a tiny nudge to give Harima an opportunity. The ultimate decision is still Tenma's.
The ultimate decision in who Harima likes is still Harima’s, too, despite other people pushing him onto Eri.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
Even if Harima is a little bit attracted to Eri, he still doesn't want a relationship with her at all.
If Harima’s feelings for Eri are in doubt now, we can’t be certain “he doesn’t want a relationship with her at all,” anymore.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
But Akira should know that pushing her friend towards a boy who doesn't return her affections could hurt Eri. Of course, it IS Akira; she is neither benevolent nor infallible and likes to mess with her friends to make them uncomfortable.
Yakumo should know that pushing her sister towards a man Tenma doesn’t like could hurt Tenma.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
That was bound to happen anyway, as soon as Eri accepted the truth.
If Yakumo had left things be, then I’d have agreed that she’s absolved from blame. As it stands, Yakumo decided to get involved, and now she has a share of the blame in Eri and Tenma’s dilemma.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
Yakumo is giving Harima a chance. She isn't doing anything for or against Karasuma.
I know she’s giving Harima a chance, and by doing so she’s placing Harima above Karasuma. She’s decided that Harima is the better choice for Tenma without seeing how Karasuma would fare in a relationship with Tenma. Hence, she’s not giving Karasuma a chance, as I said in my previous post.

Originally Posted by
NeoSapien
Hard to say. She would probably either accept it and move on or confront Harima to confirm his feelings and make sure he was being true to himself.
It would put Yakumo in a position for character development and I’d like to see her get some more development, so that’s why I’d like to see Yakumo in that position.

Originally Posted by
Mini Jesus
Here's my theory, which may have been stated already since I don't have time to read through the thread at the moment...
I think Yakumo is pushing Harima and Tenma together because she wants what's Best for her sister. She doesn't just blindly follow her sisters lead and go with whatever she says all the time. She thinks Harima will make her happier than Karasuma, and is thusly trying to get Tenma to see it too....
Ugh, I can't explain it right at the moment, that's kinda it but I'll be back later to try and refine it and actually get my point across.
It’s complex, isn’t it? It sure would help a lot if we had more chapters focused on Yakumo’s feelings regarding Oudou to use as reference.
Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster. And if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the abyss will gaze back into you. - Friedrich Nietzsche
Bookmarks