Thread: is school rumble worth to be called best manga ever?

i don't think this manga worth
indeed it is very funny
indeed it's chara is lovable
indeed it's addictive
but the story isn't adequate to be called best manga

i, myself, call this manga had the best chara ever, harima kenji of course..

It is not the best mangas ever but it is one of the best for me indeed

not best manga ever, but best romantic comedy for me

yep..not best manga ever..but it is one of the best

SR is like my top favourites, in classification as "Best Romantic Comedy" it takes first place (Love Hina second i think, I would say Ranma 1/2 would be third, but 50 % of this manga is about fighting).

..But as a "Best manga ever"... It's probably not, although I don't know which manga could actually best...

If we were to say that "The Best manga" is the manga which makes you want more RIGHT KNOW and you just can't stop reading.. SR is in the same time first and third at my list (third because I have two super-favorite manga... who already ended, first if we don't count those two)

No manga is "the best manga ever", but this manga is very unique. It is both more realistic than other romance managas in that it shows the logic of hs students and less realistic in its comedic elements.

Manga has way too many classifications and target audiences.

For me SR is one of the top mangas that I'm reading.
I like it for the characters and Plot but the story moves too slowly for me. I guess its because every characters are being introduce and given some time to develop. And theres a lot of them (and more to come) ^.^"

not da best but i really enjoy this manga very much

its my favorite manga right now, but i cant say its the best ever but i will dare say its the best romantic/comedy manga i know :P
it also has some of my favorite characters ever, Harima and Eri

Yeah, the best romantic comedy. It should be the best among same genre manga