I'm basing my opinion on the ability to play the file not only on my computer but my dvd player too. I do like Guerosama better though and the translations are not that bad at all. I think both are pretty equal actualy. But I do agree K-F will be the group Ill eventualy replace them with unless they run REALY behind then I'de choose Guerosama.
I don't generally re-watch episodes, but I download Gerusama nowadays after watching ADC.
I especially liked that Gerusama put out the 4th TV Special which adc ignored. It was probably the best OP filler I've seen
Come on now, I don't think Gerusama's is that bad, just because the RAWs are not DVD's... His work is quite good, you must admit.
Actually, no. Chopper's Voice Actor is on maturnaty leave. It was confirmed after the whole sickness thing.
Originally Posted by pentaelemental
Gerusama and adc are both pretty good...adc improved alot.
i like how both are widescreen.
watch them all!
one piece is one of the few series i can stand watch more than once.
Dont get why people go crazy over k-f (stop kissin ass) , yes they are good but the way people talk is a bit nutty...
The widescreen is not a fansub issue. One Piece wasn't broadcast in widescreen until episode 207. K-F only got to episode 176 so far, while Gerusama started from 219, well after widescreens started.
since k-f have been useing the dvd sources i assume theyd have been able to go widescreen long before the hdtv raws appeared?
when i see big verbs flying around in comparisons, the first thing i think of is this kind of conversation ive had before....
ie: someone mentions how a translation is sooo much better than *insert series/group name* ...
ask if they speak japanese themselves, more often than not they dont...
so how do you know if its better or not.
y'know what imean? thats a case of kiss assiness, when someone just jumps on a bandwagon. :P
yes there are differences, k-f's vid source is better and they do pay attention to small details,
but as some people go as far as to call others Shit when the differences are not that great... oh yeah, thats ass kissing.
Last edited by epocs; 03-04-2006 at 05:24 PM.
Gerusama's newspost said "replacements were referred to as temporary." So the current replacements are still temporary. Unless the info is inaccurate.
Originally Posted by XP_OMG11
Huh? Why? That would require redoing the whole 206 episodes in HDTV format for DVD release...
Originally Posted by epocs
That is apparently a problem. Notice that with episode 207, not only the format changes. OP and ED songs switch at the same time, and there is even a new eyecatcher! That all points to the theory that it was easier to do all those things anew than to adapt the existing ones.