Thread: Who would win?

I know this is a frequently asked question, but in a fight between Luffy and Zorro at their current level who would win? Befor Luffy got his gears I would have said Zorro but with gear 2 and 3 combined against that six-arms-three-head-attack I'd pick Luffy. On the other hand Luffy would faint after using that attack so it could be considered a draw and let's not forget that the blade (and heat) is Luffys greatest weaknesses.
Now their speed and physical strength is about the same, so it's Devilfruit against Swordsmanship.

Who would you choose (and please don't give Luffy the "but-he's-the-main-character-bonus")??????



Other interesting fights among the crew:

-Zorro vs Robine. I'd say Zorro cuz he can move faster than the eye can see and Robine needs to have visual contact on the target to use her abbility

- Nami vs Usop: It's a battle of mindes but I'll chose Usop cuz of the reach-advantage

-Franky vs chopper: togh one.......Chopper?

But what do you think and what other interesting fights could there be in the One-Piece-universe?

Zorro wins cuz he simply slashed everyone into pieces.

I'd say Zoro. He may be ko after the fight, but luffy's arms or feet would be sliced so...

I can't pick a winner as i think that Luffy never gives up in a fight and always finds away to win. Also I know that swords should be Luffy's biggest weakness, but Ive yet to see a sword pierce him I think he has the potential to bend around the sword blade making him not get hurt. I no this is a pretty big and probably impossible thing but i think theres a small chance it can work after all we know bullets don't pierce him, but then again they aren't sharp. Even if Luffy couldn't be hurt by normal blades as Zoro has learnt to cut through most things by now i think that he would cut Luffy, making all the stuff ive been rambling on about stupid (sorry guys- just me thinking out loud). But yeah neither of them ever give up, in past fights i think Luffy can take out stronger foes but then Zoro isn't exactly weak in any way and he has the sword advantage. My money would be on Luffy but i just can't tell still.

i'd say luffy, because with gear 2 he can move extremely fast and even though zoro is quite fast too, he won't be able to keep up. Without gear 2 it's zoro hands down since as strong as luffy is, both of them can take a lot of pain, but zoro has the advantage of being able to cut off luffy's arms/legs while luffy can only deal pain.

My choice: It's a draw, given the facts other mention.

I'd take Zoro over Luffy. Yeah Luffy has gear 2, but Zoro has experience fighting shichibukai users so I think think that nullifies that. Also I think that gear 3 is mute since, as previously mentioned, Zoro can cut anything. so in the end I think that it comes down to sword versus fist. Somehow I can't pick fist in that.

I do however think that Robin would beat Zoro since she is a grappler with great reach. In that fight Zoro might not even get to draw his swords.

Given that we have seen what Ussop can do when he knows his opponent (fight with Luffy), I think that Ussop would win hands down.

I'll take Franky because I no matter how mad he is, I doubt that Chopper would use his rumble ball 3 times.

Also, no Sanji fights? I have to admit that I too had a difficult time thinking of a Sanji fight. He's part of the monster trio, but he can't hurt Luffy unless he uses the Diablo Jamble. See above for what I think of his fight with Zoro. Also see above to see what I think he would do against a grappler like Robin. He would also lose to Robin and Nami because of his ethical leanings (doesn't hit women). Yet I think that he obliterates Chopper and Ussop. The only one that leaves out is Franky. I like this fight because it brings Sanji's unstoppable leg against a steel body. I still think Sanji wins, but at least it's interesting.

^ I disagree about Robin, she is way too weak to be able to stop Zoro if he really wants to fight.

Sanji would only lose against Nami and Robin, but that's it Seriously he would own anyone beside these 2 and maybe Zoro and Luffy, though if Luffy was hit by his Diablo jambe he would be in a very bad state..

It would be a draw. Swords/Sharp objects are Luffy's real weakness and Zoro is a a master with the swords. Plus the recent chapters show that Zoro can take some heavy damage and keep standing, so it would be hard for Luffy to defeat him without hurting himself just as bad.

Even tho, looking at when Luffy and Zoro actually did fight it was quite even (around chapter 112), so I'd say that the outcome would depend alot on chance in that one.