Thread: Who would win?

what about franky vs brook

Well if brook can cut steel/iron then brook because of his extreme speed but since fencers are known for their not so strong swords that are very fast I'm thinking he can't which means he'd have to approach franky from behind which franky could put all effort into protecting.

So either brook or franky pending his ability to cut metal

Nah... the one who would pwn them all is Nami!!! lulz jk...

seriously.. in a real fight... I'd say they're equal... It's because Luffy trained in hell just to be actually fighting on his own like that plus the fact that he had been training with the Gomu Gomu no Mi for 10 years... Zoro had to train his body just to actually have immense strength plus his pirate hunting days...

Probably Luffy, he has that insane stamina and endurance factor on his side.

well for me i think Luffy still stronger than other SH
which is he can beat any of his crew
it's not becoz he is the main character..it juz he is promise to protect his friend all along
if he is equal with one of other crew than how could he still protecting.....
other thing is up till this moment it seem every pirate captain stronger than their crew

anyway i think if there is serious fight between zoro and sanji it could be very scary one which could be draw conclusion...

then between chopper and franky...i believe franky better than chopper 2nd rumble ball, but when he take the 3rd one...maybe he can match up with zoro and sanji.....it is if he can control his mind...

Luffy is stronger than any of his crew. It just as simple as that

I will reconsider my opinion if Zorro can defeat the Eagle Eye sword

of course Luffy....the reason???..I think the other member has answered it,,,,

It would be draw. There is no reason for them to fight extremely. I think they wont use unque skill to fight to die.

Every captain in every crew we've seen in one piece has been the strongest in his crew, I doubt Zoro would follow someone weaker than him.

That doesnt necessarily mean that Zoro is weaker than Luffy. We know how egotistical Zoro is. When Zoro first joined the crew, i seriously doubt he believed Luffy's strength was greater than his own. So why did he join? something else is behind that unwavering loyalty.

Hmmm. Luffy vs. Zoro. I really want to see round two of this fight =D. I think Zoro will win, but being a Zoro fan, I'm biased. People have commented saying Zoro might not be able to cut Luffy. He can cut ANYTHING. Also mentioned was the possibility that Zoro could not possibly defeat enemies that Luffy had. But did he ever get the chance to fight them? The greatest weapon of the two is the fact that they both rise to meet the challenges before them.
I seriously wanna see them both go all out against each other. Say, Zoro killed Usopp, and Luffy broke the white sheathed katana. The ensuing fight would be fun to watch =P.

Zoro vs. Robin. If it comes down to combat ability, I'd say Zoro, hands down. But if we applied the reason why Sanji wouldnt be able to defeat Nami or Nico Robin here, Zoro wouldnt be able win. All comes down to one thing: Nico Robin's a woman.

Nami vs. Usopp. Nami wins >_<. Moving on...

Chopper vs. Franky. i just wanna see them duke it out. The buff Chopper vs. Franky. a tough call, but I'd go with Franky. Just feels better.