Thread: Who would win?

if Zoro cuts Luffy's arms then Luffy won't be able to recover... Of course Zoro might be KO but Luffy doesn't have much chances to win IMHO.

That's assuming he can cut Luffy's arm off.

if luffy is going to punch him he just has to put his swords in the directions where the arm will come from to make spaghettis... It's not a big deal really !

Well, Luffy might kick while blocking Zoro's attacks.
And the fight that they did have, while short, was extreamly even.

That's only if he can predict and react fast enough to Luffy's punch and if Luffy can't react in time to change the direction of his punch. Just because Zoro uses swords doesn't mean he can cut down Luffy. You seem to imply that Zoro can cut down any opponents who's not logia type, who doesn't use weapons nor has an impenetrable armor or skin. If that's the case, Zoro should be able to beat Garp, Sengoku and Black Beard ( I'm assuming that none of those guys use weapons to fight, but I might be wrong on this).

I just assume that Luffy's weakness is blades, as it has been stated several time by Oda...
Also, caoutchouc can be cut quite easily, so why do you think Zoro should have difficulty cutting him ? Of course it is only speculation, but from what we know I'd give Zoro the advantage.

If Luffy's weakness is blades, then it's also everyones' weaknesses too except for those few that can't be cut. So I suppose Zoro can beat every character in One Piece that can be cut and doesn't have weapon to defend themselves, that includes possibly shichibukai and vice admirals, admirals, supreme admiral and the pirate emperors, right?

I think Luffy could evade Zoro's attacks, but if Luffy is the one attacking, Zoro just needs to block with one of his sword attacks and cut Luffy's arms. So I'd say Zoro.
Now if Luffy were to take a sword or swords and attack Zoro, that would be another story.

That Zorro could cut Ruffy with a blade is clear. But the question is, would he be able to do it.
I doubt he can react fast enough to land a hit on Ruffy when he's using gear 2nd. But Zorro can take a beating and it sure would be an intersting fight.
But in the end, Ruffy is the best.

Originally Posted by animefan

If Luffy's weakness is blades, then it's also everyones' weaknesses too except for those few that can't be cut. So I suppose Zoro can beat every character in One Piece that can be cut and doesn't have weapon to defend themselves, that includes possibly shichibukai and vice admirals, admirals, supreme admiral and the pirate emperors, right?

Are you for real ??
The others have weapons to protect themselves, Luffy doesn't. Name me one shichibukai, vice admiral, admiral, supreme admiral or pirate emperor who couldn't protect himself against a sword, please ??