Thread: Who would win?

I don't think that you can write off Robin so quickly. The only person to really beat her was Crocodile.she has already shown that she can slap away Zoro's swords, and she has beaten someone physically strong in Skypeia. Plus we haven't really seen her in a fight like we have with Zoro. Zoro's fights are always drawn out with him taking a lot of damage, and showing his abilities to the furthest. I think that Robin has more unshown potential.

Fight between zoro and luffy i think it depends on the field too but no matter what zoro will win, i don't know how but somehow

fight between bare-handed and sword?mehhh sword will win

Inner crew fighting is never a good thing... But if it were to happen...

Luffy could beet Zoro.. it would be a long, rough fight, but Luffy is WAY stronger than zoro, and fast enough to evade or block at the hilt.

Zoro would beat Sanji... but again, it would be a very good fight..

Sanji would lose to the girls... with a single bat of their eyelashes... but could beat the rest without losing his cigarette.

Franky is the next strongest, followed by chopper... unsure where Brooke lands, but I think he's there with franky.

Nami could beat them all cause the whole crew fear her!!!!!!!

Seriously, Nami, ussopp, and Robin all work by outsmarting opponents. Against each other, battles could go any way.. whoever had the best trick, wins. On that note, Ussopp has a big bag of ever evolving tricks. I'd give him a chance of take Franky or chopper...

Of course, this question may actually be important soon... isn't don flamenco supposed to be a mind controller?

I wouldn't know the outcome of a fight between the two. Logically speaking, it would probably end up as a draw. They can easily read each other's moves, and before chapter 485 was released I always thought that the two were on par.

I'd say it all depends on luck. Everyone on the SH crew's lucky as far as I know, and to see Lady Luck bless one member more so than the other during a critical time will be most amusing...

And no, I really don't think Robin would win against Zoro... I can see her trying, but she's still vulnerable when using her DF. Robin specializes in mid-range to long range combat, and specifically stealth/assassination. Zoro's not careless around her at all, and I wouldn't want my limbs grabbing him anywhere when even with bare hands, he could tear my flesh off by substituting it for a sword anyways. It's a no-no. D :

Originally Posted by Shardan

Of course, this question may actually be important soon... isn't don flamenco supposed to be a mind controller?

Nope, as far as I can tell, he just controls a person's actions rather than state of mind. Check back on Chap. 303, Sarquiss didn't want to do that to Bellamy, he just couldn't make his actions stop.

What Shardan said can still happen even if doflamingo can only control the actions, though we can wonder if he can use the techniques of the people he controls ? Or just use their body as he wants (which seems more likely as he doesn't control their minds, and would render the hypothetical fight of luffy and zoro pointless)

I think Zoro will definitely win .

Definitely Luffy. Zoro had not beaten the kind of opponents that Luffy had to face. Remember the CP9 fight and how much stronger Luchi was as oppose to that long nose CP9 dude that Zoro faced?

It was the same with every other Boss later in the series. Zorro also wouldn't have beaten Enel, Croc or Arlong.
But probably all the earlier Bosses like Krieg, Buggy, Kuro and Wapol.

luffy will kill him with gear2, maybe badly injured, but he'll won, he doesnt get 300 million bounty for nothin'.
hmmm luffy also can take a lot of damage more than zorro, he can can take damage from moria and still can beat him, but when the damage transferred to zorro by kuma, he can barely standing.
anyway, it's just theory