Most tragic past

my vote:

1. Robin 2. Chopper 3. Nami 4. Franky 5. Zorro 6. Sanji 7. Luffy 8. Usopp

I mean despite growing up without his parents, Usopp had a pretty nice and happy life.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by chinsee

my vote:

I mean despite growing up without his parents, Usopp had a pretty nice and happy life.

---

Luffy Zorro and Sanji had kinda happy lives too there was only one tragic incedent. I think mother dying and being the village liar is worse than ones best friend dying or ones hero loosing an arm or being stranded on an island.

i'd say zorro's and luffy's lives were both happier than usopp's, but being stranded on an island as sanji was is worse than these other 3...

so :
1. Robin 2. Chopper 3. Nami 4. Franky 5. Sanji 6. Usopp 7. Zorro 8. Luffy

You all haven't mentioned Brook! =(

it's because we barely knew him at the time :P

If I must add him and in respect to the few we know about him, the list would look like :
1. Robin 2. Chopper 3. Nami 4. Franky 5. Brook 6. Sanji 7. Luffy 8. Usopp 9. Zorro

ps : Luffy as gained some places thanks to his grandfather love :p

man his grandfather love is trying to kill him that would scar anyone for life in my opinion

i would go

1.Robin 2.Chopper 3.Nami 4.Sanji 5.Usopp 6.Zoro 7.Luffy

dont know quite frankly where to put franky cuz i dont really understand enough about his past because all i really remember is him losing his shadow his uncanny willingness to live that he ate a devil fruit that makes him like that and the death of his entire crew but theres not enough info there so if i would have to place him it would be right before sanji

1. Robin
2. Chopper
3. Nami
4. Zoro