Thread: Who Is The Better Swordsman Now??

Originally Posted by Ayato_kamina

Am i the only one seeing whitebeard using a halberd (i think) a bit of a technicality just so he isnt a swordsman and hence not the strongest swordsman in the world? ... a bit silly if you ask me.

Whitebeard uses a bisento but I hope its not his only power and that it's just a weapon he uses to battle swordsman such as Shanks. I mean if it was his real and only attack form then it would probably mean that Roger is also a swordsman or uses a similar weapon to which he would fight Whitebeard with. That would make too many swordsman right?

I think we already kno that roger's a swordsman. and yeah, a ton of people use swords in one piece. i dont really care tho

yea, roger used swords, you could see that in that skull the old man showed luffy in one piece, the giant killer's skull, it had a clear sword cut in it.

definitely shanks, even though he has one arm/one sword. even up against zoro's three swords.

yes shanks would own zoro easely....

Zoro told Luffy he will not lose anymore so i assume that Zoro will not lose and beat Shanks IF he faces him. He will only lose from now on if theres a twist at the end where he loses to Mihawk again and comes back and wins 3rd time lucky.

i ges santoryu is mch better than one arm...
Shank's spirit has nothing to do with zoro... wud U think he(zoro) wud collapse wyl Shanks s around... it wont happen...
Zoro has the devil spirit too... hee.hee

but the possibility that both of them wud draw swords against each other, s almost zero...
Mihawk, s the only goal for zoro... and wud not lose to him anymore...
be the Worlds greatest swordsman, Zoro...

pardon my intrusion but 4 now i say shanks is stronger than zoro but who knos wat will happen in the future. anyways i dun think that shanks n zoro will have a duel anytime soon

To be honest I thought the skull was only in the anime? I don't consider the anime 100% canon so until theres something similar or more definitive in the manga then Roger fought however the hell he wanted Besides there are examples of unarmed individuals equally facing armed individuals consider Luffy and Zoro's little fight in Whiskey Peak.

Oh god, I hope this isn't the start of all those "@#$@#! Vs. #@$#%!" thread that has been closed by Jyuu at the Naruto section.

It's kind of pointless to speculate who would own who, since we haven't seen how Shanks fought. Truth be told, at this point, Shanks would win because of sheer REPUTATION(being a yonkou and all). Zoro would be a crowd favorite, since we've all seen him fight. Meh, why do I even bother -_-