Thread: If one of the Strawhats were to die, who to do you think it should be?

Ok then. Lets simulate Robins death after her role is over ( Im well known for digging my own grave).

Robin: finally... the incident of Ohara's truth is spoken*smiles*.
Crowd of ppl stands still. From behind Luffi knocks off the head of Marines.
Luffi: I won the boss of Marines!!!

Later on that night at a house the crew has a party, and Robin stays up on the quiet night roof.
Robin: When I light this match, I feel I could still see the good memories of the ppl of Ohara.
* Sees the giants vision, which dissapears as the flame dies*
Robin: Wait!... Dr. Clover.. I want to see u again...(tears run out, she lights another match)
* Robin sees an illusion of Dr. Clover and the other scholars, and dies again with the flame*
Robin: Mum...(lights the remaining bunch of matches)
*An illusion of Robins mum appears, and starts to fade*
Robin: Mum wait! take me with you! I wanted to hold hands with you for once!
*Robin goes up to the sky holding hands with her mum.*
Luffi: Hey, why is Robin on the floor outside? Did she fall down?

THE END*p.s. This is fiction and will neba happen wat so eva*

If Franky joins the crew I would get in and kill him that instant, but I would save Chopper 4 my life.

in all actuality thou i know no one will really die in this manga my vote goes to Zoro. when you really think about it hes the one character you really would expect to die in battle

I think before the end, the world government collapses and the marines have a tough time preventing the ensuing chaos. However, after discovering the Rio Poneglyph, Robin is able to piece together the history of an advanced lost civilization and help set up a new form of government (probably a form of democracy), Nami will complete the world map and aids Robin with creating a new world order, and Luffy would either be executed or offered a full pardon, or both (refuse pardon and get executed).

Ayato_kamina's idea is interesting. I pretty much forgot about Coby till you mentioned him, haha.

Well I think Coby will be brought back sometime in the future, but not as a crew member or anything; just for the purpose of furthering the story. It'd be ironic, really, if Coby was the one executing Luffy.

Nonetheless, I think Chopper has the highest chance of getting killed (although I'm pretty sure none of the characters will die), as he's a doctor, and the kindest/more compassionate of the crew in my opinion. I can imagine him talking about Hiruluk (is that how it's spelt?) just before he dies, saying that he achieved his dream or something...

Originally Posted by pentaelemental

Luffy: Fate, strong will (and damage resistance)
Zoro: Inhuman endurance and recovery (a bajillion hp), luck
Sanji: Mellorine power, agility
Ussop: Runs and hides too much, thick skull, fakes death
Nami: Smart, uses allies as shield, surrenders easily
Chopper: 3 rumble balls *spoiler*
Robin: Smart, cheap and efficient techniques
Franky: Cyborg, made of steel

Most likely to die and reasons:
1. Sanji: self sacrifice for girls
2. Chopper: too naive and unaware
3. Ussop: unlucky, slow reflexes
4. Nami: low stamina, slow reflexes
5. Robin: unsocial
6. Franky: bad attitude, fuel
7. Zoro: too self-reliant
8. Luffy: stupidity

i dont see franky joining the crew

I can't really see Luffy actually dying in the manga. I can see him being captured, scentenced to execution, and be seen smiling in the last panel just like Gold Roger, but thats it. If they were to have anything after Luffy smiling, it would either be him taking out the executioner and getting away, or the rest of the crew begining the assault on the marines there.

Originally Posted by Rocklee87

i dont see franky joining the crew

Look farther.

Originally Posted by Ayato_kamina

Oh well. I think luffy will die :P at the end of one piece, he'll start a new age of pirates and then be executed by coby but him and coby will still be friends, despite being on different sides. Luffy will die with a great big smile on his face, just like gold roger.

The end

If luffy was to be executed in the end it would probably be the end of the glorious piracy era since the strawhats is bound to beat all other pirates to smitherens long before that

no 1s gonna die, its would ruined the anime , but if some 1 were to die it would be in a heroic way like pel, but he really didnt die but if he did , he would of been cooler

lol its not like u can do that, if u did oda would scout ur !@#$ and fry it like a chiken wing