Thread: Anime Vs. Manga

Mahou Sensei Negima, 1st season... really disapointing.
Well, i'm glad i read the manga first or i wouldn't have bothered reading it if i watch the anime first.

Dun you people think its drawn a bit wierd?

I rather liked it. Well, I always watch anime first so I can enjoy it instead of moaning about how they messed up the spoilers from manga. No offense; talking about people who do that in general. At least first season artwork is more similar to manga artwork than second season.

I find second season really strange... I'll just treat it as an alternate universe.

I prefer manga...

I agree with Tagno. Generally it's much better to see anime first and then to read manga. Usually manga is much more detailed then anime. If I had seen MSN anime before manga I guess I'd like much more then I currently do.

The anime ending sorta showed what was not shown in the manga.

The manga is so much better than the animes that the quality level isn't even in the same league.

manga for me....
for you infomation..
negima got 4 version in japan.
one was the original from ken akamatsu,one was negima neo and other 2,i dont know the name.

manga for me. actually i would say don't even think about comparing them together.

Sorry for saying this but... didnt we have a thread about this already? this one....

well on topic the manga is the best and I agree that it shoulndt be compared to the anime not even the new one (Negima!?) or the other new manga (Negima Neo), because the original is on a whole different level (ok it stars slow but it is great) that is like comparing a CD to a DVD well not that extreme but you get the idea.