Rate The Gantzers!

Well I was thinking a thread like this could lead to some rather interesting discussion, Everyone pick a Gantzer, list their pros and cons and rate them on a scale of 1 - 10.

I'm gonna start with Katou since i think he's one of the more controversial gantzers (maybe not as much after ch. 251)

Pros:
Katou has always been extremely brave, during the onion mission he tried to hold the big alien still so that Kurono could get away (or was it shoot him? to long ago to remember clearly), not knowing what would happen. In the buddha mission, after kurono, sei, hojo, sayaka, the sniper guy, kishimoto and a handful of others were defeated by the thousand arms statue he figured out a way to beat it, sure he died, but if it wasnt for him then kurono wouldnt have survived and who knows what would happen later on. In the osaka mission he's proven that being dead for half a year hasnt slowed him down any, in fact, he might have gotten better, he's fought with the Host Samurai, taken down an Alien about to eat that family, and now (spoiler for anyone who hasnt read ch. 251) He's beaten an alien that three expert Gantzers, all with the BFGs couldn't!

Cons:
Katou's ability is severely hindered due to the fact that he'll only use the capture gun. He'd have a lot easier time with some of these aliens if he'd just blow them to bits instead of fighting hand to hand with each and every one of them. Also, he wants to protect everyone, but the best he can do is 'go hide!' and then they get killed. If he wants them to put the suits on and really cares whether they live or die he should do something like threaten them while they're still in the room or something. Also, Kurono said he was trying to be like Katou, who, Ironically was trying to emulate himself, but i don't really think Katou was a competent leader, he had a hard time keeping control under pressure, and in the Buddha arc when he sent out two teams he had the two best gantzers (Kurono and himself) go one way, and hojo, sayaka, and a bunch of guys without suits go the other way, kind of setting them up for disaster, dont you think?


Soooo To Sum It Up:
Good: Strong, Brave, Smart Thinking when it comes to taking on aliens 1v1
Bad: Wont blow things up, Makes bad decisions as a leader, tries to hold order, but cant.

So My Ratings:
Leader: 6/10
Urmm....Not Leader: 8/10

Feel free to debate me on this, i mean, thats why i'm posting it, no?

Katou:

• Pro:
  • Thinks before acting.
  • Experienced with missions and weapons.
  • Willing to wade into melee and give the opposition a great big hug.
• Con:
  • Thinks too much. Has a tendency to deliberate in situations that demand immediate action.
  • Hesitant. His lack of ruthlessness may make him a better person, but it slows him down, especially in combination with the previous point.
  • Limited in weapon choice. The Y-gun hasn't shown any total countermeasures the way the X-gun simply fails to work on some aliens, and isn't blockable the way that the sword is, but its results have been spotty, and it failed at least once against the most recent alien. Acts slowly, so aliens with medium- to long-range weapons may be able to injure or kill during transport.

__________________
Failure: when your best just isn't good enough.

Also katou does not panic easily not even when the 1000 arm cut off his arm, which is an important trait to survive in Gantz.

Nobody minds if I do two? Kaze, Muscle Rider, Country side general.

Pros: He's very powerful. He was able to match Kurono's power even without a suit when they had that fight.
Fearless. I don't think he's afraid of anything unless it's...
He's willing to fight with everyone and cooperate on teams.
He's smart, he tries to figure out how to beat his opponents.

Cons: He doesn't use the guns. He hasn't mastered how to use the gantz guns. If he did, I'm sure there would be more people saying that he is the best and not Kurono or Izumi.
Too brave? He goes into battle without a weapon and not knowin what his enemies are capable of and that can lead to his downfall.
He doesn't have great leadership skills.

Rating: 8... 10 if he masters how to use the guns.

Joichiro Nishi: My personal favorite.

Pros: Acts mature for his age.
Tries to keep a cool head.
Understands his goals and objectives and does what he needs to do to accomplish them.
He was able to survive by himself for a year.
Made a strategy that seemed to be foolproof.
He seems to be very intelligent.
He wan't really reckless.
He has alot of info about Gantz that we still don't know.

Cons: He's a psycho. ^_^
He doesn't seem to have mastered all the weapons. That mission where he died (and constantly gets flamed for) the Gantz sword would've really helped him.
He was unwilling to tell people what was goin on so that lead to his teammates dying.
Doesn't seem to like to be on a team and cooperate.
Doesn't seem to have respect for his teammates.
I don't think he had the mentality to be ready for anything since he didn't seem to have some solution to his suit being broken and not being invisible.
The last three lead to his downfall and possibly will again.

Rating: 8, just because he seems really intelligent and he understands what he's doing and he was able to survive on his own as a kid for so long. Yes, I know he jumped in the damn water!

We don't know how much of that year was spent with Izumi's team.

My guess is that Nishi was alone for 3-4 missions before Kurono and Katou arrived.

Yeah, that was just my guess. He's still a mystery.

That isn't a con. I would even say that being a psycho is somewhat useful in Gantz.

As to his time without Izumi...remember, he said early on that it had been quite a while since anyone else had survived. He had been alone for a long time.

__________________

To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

When did Nishi become trustworthy?

Why should he lie about the time he has been with Gantz?

I'm not saying that he lied about how long he was a Gantzer.

What I am proposing is that he simply exaggerated how long it had been since someone returned alive with him.