I agree with Adonai
even thought having a Rambo wouldn't hurt.
I frankly don't care how this game is set up. Just count me in.
It would be nice to play a complex game, but I don't think we have enough players or enough time (among players) to pull off a packed game effectively (last time was Hanul's).
Curiously, why is everyone suddenly busy now? It's the summer, so it should be less busy unless you're working....
Stolen Sig Count: 26
I'm still all for whatever happens. I just want to play, and hopefully win. >_>
Personally, I think the roles look like it'll make the game more interesting.
I want to see more active people so that was my thought behind a lot of it. The coroner was a role for this reason in the past, lately it has just been removed and everyone knows what everyone was. The Fool I just thought would be funny, it would give the person playing reason to be careful when they post. I also could see quite a few people faking that role. I liked the idea of an incorrect ping. However having a crazy seer or whatever never worked well, and having a hidden mafia always shot townies in the foot unless they didn't count toward the win total. Giving the whore aids from the start is a bit OP imo and we honestly need only one type of viewing role in game.
As for the three way thing I realize having a third group has been fucked before, honestly I wouldn't mind trying it again, but a Rambo would be cool too. Keeping the priest would still be an option then but it would require some tuning. Necromancer has been done in the past, I honestly think it's a bit OP considering it means that usually a townie will be brought back every few days. With the Rambo in the mix this might not be so bad.
Fine tuning the rules I that I want/have considered now, I'll post them in a bit. Also we need more people talking about the best time for everyone.
throw me into this one as well
Im in =)
Though Im too sure about some of the roles..
Vincent wants in!
I like the shifty villager. I don't mind having that role ^^
btw regarding the Mafioso boss. You stated that they can't be killed if the other mafias are alive yet you said we get an extra kill if we kill him. so... which one is right? can we or can't we kill the mafioso boss even if his underlings are at large?
Mafia boss can't make mafia kills without his underlings.
Originally Posted by _Vincent_
He can't be lynched unless a large % of the living players vote for him. Even if three people vote and there are twelve for instance. His role will be revealed the next day.
So the decision is to kill him or not, because if you do kill him and there are mafia members left other than him they get two kills that night.
The big tip off though is if you know who he is and no other mafia kills are being made.
Sorry I realize it is complicated, I didn't seem that way in my head.
Cool anything you think would work badly/want to change/add. Just post it here, the game won't start for a bit yet. So I am open to change and criticism.
Originally Posted by Raszagal
I'll think about the roles later