I agree with picking apart Sirusboon narrative rather then pure coincidence that someone checked their pm's. For that reason i will vote Jakko as well as i feel like Kaom and Kiam have made valid points and i don't think a case can be made on anyone else that convincing.
not day 1. The fact that mgs was killed on the first day, and that he was the seer is pure co-incidence
^ To rypkord- sirus boon clearly stated that all the information given in the story is true (about seers wolves psycho's etc.)
Look guys I'm not trying to insult anyone or something here, we only have 2 chances of getting a vampire. If jakko is the cultist then we should ignore him and go for the wolves. We can't afford anything else.
Edit: I change my vote for rypkord. but u-sama still should be voted off second. If the schizophrenic is still alive, please use your skill tomorrow on a likely candidate. (not today tomorrow). There's a high chance that you could get killed.
Last edited by bipolargraph; 09-27-2007 at 03:53 AM.
^Right now, there is more strong reason to lynch Jakko, than Rypkord or Urameshi.
It looks like the Guardian is dead, no one is protected (no underlined name).
By looking at yesterday's story:
I just noticed something,
I think that sentence, "Silver bars, weapons, fencing..." is a clue that Evail is the Guardian. I wouldn't be surprised if Jakko was contacted by Evail before day2 because he said he was pinged. Evail probably just took his word without noticing what that means exactly. Also If day2 story can be believed, then seer is dead too fromday1 story. Sorry for doubting the stories, I just didn't expect Sirus to give such an obvious clue (Day1). I would have acted earlier if I read these more carefully. Jakko.That night Jakko felt really secure for some reason, he slept without any troubles. The same could not be said for Evail who had just returned home from work. His door was open a crack, which was odd because he had remembered locking it. Opening it all the way he peered inside. Silver bars, weapons, fencing among other things were strewn about, things which he had kept hidden. He walked inside and the door shut behind him, jumping he turned to view the one who had shut the door, A large warg grinned back, he turned to run but was confronted by another. Someone in a wolf mask spoke up from the dinning room, "Forget trying, there is no escape from here." Evail screamed bloody murder as he was killed. Knowing it would alert those near by the three fled into the night. With that the villagers lost all hope.
Hmmm, it seems you misunderstood my last post. I was saying that we should pick apart and look for clues in sirusboon's message...i understand it is all true. What was coincidence was the fact of you wanting to vote off urameshi due to looking at their inbox at a certain time and that is it.
The fact that you will not vote for Jakko and the fact that you were adamant that we vote off urameshi makes me believe urameshi more and more and you less and less.
^ Looking at an inbox at that time is really a clue, but it could mean nothing. You don't have to believe me, but the only way that you'd be sure that I'm a townie is after I die, in which I hope the wolves kill me rather than a lynch.
Flash-I think I missed that part about the weapons. Well then, all evidence leads to Jakko since everyone wants him dead. I hope that he's a wolf not a cultist.
Edit: this is what jakko said in the second day.
"No, I heard nothing from the seer. This is, to say the least, disheartening. Guardian, I understand if you do not want to tell me who you are, afterall, you have only my word(such as it is), that I was pinged by the seer, and am a townie."
Well I'm guessing since jakko doesn't lie then he's a cultist probably. Lets see what he has to say.
Edit 2: Here's his list of suspects.
"At this point, everything is speculation. My money is on, in this order:
Tomorrow Sirusboon is going to put up a double story(I hope), if it really turns out that jakko is the cultist, then I say we go ahead with urameshi sama since his name is not on this list.
It would be safer to go for urameshi sama first since jakko's probably the cultist (I know I said that before).
Last edited by bipolargraph; 09-27-2007 at 05:19 AM.
^well where i come from..."doesn't lie" in not an argument that is able to proof anything, can we proof it?
no we can't of course we can't...
I consider myself a honest person, but I'd never say I never lie..
It's quite impossible...
but even so, a person who "doesn't lie" ist the same as a person who swears to whoever...it just kills tht fun of the game...
maybe jakko should host a game, the we all can just PM him and ask "who are the wolfs"
or "is ... the wolf?" since he "doesn't lie"...
Maybe it could be a role for the next game: the "truth teller". he must always tell the truth...
It's highly possible that Jakko is a wolf/cultist.
He was pinged on night-0 and it looks like the wolfs hit the seer on the same time, which was pure luck. Jakko saw that the seer is most likely dead and revealed that he was pinged. At the same time he requested to be protected and the guardian trusted and PMed him, saying that he will protect him tonight. Then the wolfs killed the guardian.
I somehow like that idea... how else could the wolfs kill seer AND guardian that easy?
Everything is based on the information given in the story.
Maybe Sirus gave us that much info on purpose and if we say the information is real, Jakko is most likely a wolf/cultist.